Pickens Carried Friedman’s Torch
By Eve Tahmincioglu

Almost every story on the origins of corporate American’s shareholder-centric approach includes a history lesson on economist Milton Friedman and his role in bolstering the concept that many believe has led to a short-term approach to company success, undermining innovation and employees.

Friedman’s theory, however, was propelled by corporate raiders such as T. Boone Pickens, who died last month at the age of 91.

A few obituaries about the “aw-shucks” billionaire’s corporate legacy included a few lines about how Pickens — who founded the United Shareholders Association in 1986 — espoused the mantra that companies need to focus on the interest of the stockholders above all else.

 

THE PURPOSE DEBATE Introduction

Where corporate America has been, and where it needs to go.

By Robert Rock

 

Back to the ‘80s: Business Roundtable’s “Purpose” Statement Redux

The group’s 1981 statement called for corporations to be “a positive force in society.” What’s different this time?

By Kristin Bresnahan

 

Three Problems With the Stakeholder Theory

Business Roundtable’s misguided decision to put shareholders last. An unpleasant déjà vu.

By Charles Elson

 

Social Good Uprooted

How America’s corporations lost their public purpose.

By David Ciepley

Pickens, a Wall Street Journal op-ed reported, “became one of the leaders of the 1980s in advocating for the primacy of shareholder value as a benchmark for corporate management. As he pointed out, companies that don’t serve the interests of their owners — the shareholders — are often serving the interests of managers who don’t have the same stake in long-term success.”

Alas, the “long-term success” he sought led to success for some, but not for so many others.

In a paper titled “The Toxic Side Effects of Shareholder Primacy,” by Lynn Stout — the former professor of corporate and business law at Cornell Law School who died last year at age 60 — she wrote:

… By the mid-1980s, many shareholders in public companies had become disillusioned. Some shareholders, such as corporate raiders Carl Icahn, T. Boone Pickens, and Ronald Perelman, saw opportunities to profit from buying stock in conglomerate firms and then pressuring their boards to break them up and sell off their pieces. This set the stage for the ascent of shareholder primacy, as academic shareholder-primacy advocates in the ivory towers gained a powerful ally in the form of shareholders (especially “activist” shareholders) themselves.

There is a growing movement to move away from the shareholder-above-all-else approach as witnessed by the recent “purpose” statement from The Business Roundtable.

At Directors & Boards magazine, we decided to dive into the purpose vs. profit debate in the stories listed to the right. Top corporate governance thought leaders share their “purpose” take on where we need to go now, and where we’ve been.

We also look at whether appointing employees as directors could bolster more equity in Corporate America; the role directors can play when it comes to driving a more inclusive culture, and the barriers faced when trying to boost the diversity imperative.

During a 1989 annual meeting of the United Shareholders Association, disbanded in 1993, Pickens said, before founding of the group:

“You didn’t hear much about the role of shareholders in America. It was a management-controlled debate. We’re starting to get the ball away from them now.” The shift, he added, “means higher productivity and a more competitive America. We’ve changed the terms of the debate.”

Time will tell where today’s changing debate will lead.

 


Issue: 
2019 Third Quarter

Other related articles

  • Director Data Q2 2020
    Published April 21, 2020
    By Directors and Boards
    Leadership Independence for SV 150 Majority Voting for SampP 100Since 2002 Fenwick amp West has surveyed the corporate governance practices of the companies included in the Standard amp Poors 100 Inde ...
  • Top of Mind: Dawn Zier, Director, Hain Celestial Group and Spirit Airlines
    Published April 21, 2020
    By Dawn Zier
    As we emerge from the pandemic we will find permanent changes and shifts in the way we do business which will force management teams and boards to navigate a new normal From dislocation and disruption ...
  • Wargaming Risk: What Military Leaders Bring to the Table
    Published April 21, 2020
    By April Hall
    When the going gets tough its easy to fall back on language that refers to war Often people are on the front line or taking on a challenge is a battle Over the years the United States has waged war on ...
  • The Key Challenges Boards Face Now
    Published April 21, 2020
    By Punita Kumar-Sinha
    The COVID19 pandemic is just beginning to take off in India in late March Nonetheless the Indian government has undertaken a preemptive 21day lockdown to flatten the curve As a result companies are al ...